| Number | Honoured Player | Seasons Played |
| 1 | Turk Broda/Johnny Bower | 1936-43, 45-52/1958-70 |
| 5 | Bill Barilko | 1946-1951 |
| 6 | Irvin "Ace" Bailey | 1927-1934 |
| Number | Honoured Player | Seasons Played |
| 7 | Francis "King" Clancy, Tim Horton | 1930-37/ 1949-1950, 51-70 |
| 9 | Ted Kennedy | 1942-55, 56-57 |
| 10 | Syl Apps | 1936-1948 |